Hello, dear friend, you can consult us at any time if you have any questions, add WeChat: THEend8_
FINS5513 Lecture 8A
Term Structure and Bond Risk 2❑ 8.1 Bond Risk: Default Spread and Term Spread ➢ Default spread ➢ Term Spread ❑ 8.2 Theories of Term Structure ➢ Expectations Hypothesis ➢ Liquidity Preference Theory • Liquidity risk and reinvestment risk ➢ Interpretation of Yield Curve Theories • Interpreting the term structure • Inverted yield curves ❑ 8.3 Interest Rate Risk ➢ Bond Price Sensitivity to Changes in Interest Rates • Maturity, coupon and YTM impacts on interest rate risk Lecture Outline 8.1 Bond Risk: Default Spread and Term Spread FINS5513 4Default Spread FINS5513 5❑ The main reason that two bonds with the same term, coupon and face value may have different yields to maturity is due to the relative likelihood of issuer default ❑ Default premiums and default spreads on risky bonds are often referred to as the risk structure of interest rates ❑ There is a difference between the yield based on expected cash flows (which prices in the risk of default) and the yield based on promised cash flows (with no default risk) ➢ The difference between the (default risk weighted) expected yield and the promised yield (i.e. the yield of an otherwise identical riskless government bond) is the default risk premium • The yield to maturity is higher for bonds with higher default risk • That is, bonds with greater default risk have a higher default risk premium Default Risk 6❑ Determination of the default risk premium on a bond is mainly driven by its credit rating ❑ Rating companies ➢ Moody’s Investor Service, Standard & Poor’s, Fitch ❑ Rating Categories ➢ Highest rating is AAA or Aaa ➢ Investment grade bonds (BBB- or Baa3 and above) ➢ Speculative grade/junk bonds (below BBB- or Baa3) ❑ Determinants of bond safety and credit rating ➢ Coverage ratios; Leverage ratios; Liquidity ratios; Profitability ratios; Cash flow-to-debt ratios Bond Credit Ratings Further Reading 8AR1: “S&P Credit Rating Essentials” 7❑ The default spread is often derived by showing the difference between yields on AAA bonds and yields on either low-level investment grade bonds (BBB-) or speculative grade high yielding bonds Default Premiums and Spreads Further Reading 8AR2: “S&P Credit Markets Update Asia Pacific - Q3 2021” 8Term Spread FINS5513 9❑ How yields change based on maturity is the term structure of interest rates (or yield curve) Term Premiums and Spreads ❑ The term spread is often a proxy for the yield curve ➢ The term spread is the yield on 10-year bonds less the yield on 90-day bills over time ➢ We have seen the yield curve is upward sloping – which means a positive term spread ➢ Allows the yield curve to be graphed over time (rather than at one point in time) and inversions easily identified Further Reading 8AR3: “Predicting Recessions Using the Term Spread” 8.2 Theories of Term Structure FINS5513 11 Expectations Hypothesis FINS5513 12 ❑ We showed previously that under certainty, we can exactly replicate cash flows of long-term bonds by reinvesting cash flows from short-term bonds: 1 + 2 2 = (1 + 1)(1 + 12) ➢ However, in reality 12 is not known with certainty at = 0 ➢ The final realized cash flow of the 2-year zero (the LHS) is known at time 0. But the final realized cash flow of the 1 year rollover strategy (the RHS) is not known with certainty at time 0 ❑ However it may be that the market has an expectation that the (certain) cash flow from the 2-year zero will equal the expected cash flow from the 1-year rollover. That is: 1 + 2 2 = (1 + 1)(1 + E(12)) ❑ This is known as the Expectations Hypothesis Expectations Hypothesis 13 ❑ Since forward rates are inferred from the term structure, a common way to denote the Expectations Hypothesis (EH) is: = () ❑ We know from the earlier generalised forward rate equation that: 1 + = (1 + ) × (1 + ) (−) Therefore under EH: 1 + = (1 + ) × (1 + ()) (−) ❑ However, the yield curve is typically upward sloping ➢ If Expectations Hypothesis were to hold, this means the market expects actual interest rates in the future to be higher than today almost all the time ➢ Perhaps there is some other explanation for the typically upward sloping yield curve? Expectations Hypothesis 14 Liquidity Preference Theory FINS5513 15 ❑ Example 8A1: You are an investor with a 1-year horizon to save $1000. You have a choice of buying either: A) a 1-year zero coupon bond and hold it to maturity; or B) a 2-year zero coupon bond and selling after 1 year a) Price a 1-year and a 2-year $1,000 zero (use the pure yield curve from 7B3) b) How many 2-year bonds would you buy (include fractions) to outlay the same amount as strategy A c) Show that strategy A is riskless (excluding default risk) while strategy B contains risk. What type of risk is this called? ➢ 1 year zero: 1 = 1000 (1.05) = $952.38 2 year zero: 2 = 1000 (1.06)2 = $890.00 ➢ Number of 2-year zeros bought to outlay the same $’s as the 1-year strategy: 952.38 890.00 = 1.0701 2-year zeros for every 1-year zero Example: Liquidity Risk 16 ➢ If the 1-year interest rate in 1 year 12 = 12 = 7.01% as predicted by the yield curve, the two strategies are equivalent: Strategy A = $1000 = Strategy B = 1,000 1.0701 × 1.0701 ➢ But what if 1-year interest rate in 1 year’s time is more (or less) than 7%? If actual rate is 6%: 1,000 1.06 × 1.0701 = $1009 > $1000 If actual rate is 8%: 1,000 1.08 x 1.0701 = $991 < $1000 ➢ The actual realised return on Strategy A is certain but the actual return on the 2-year bond is uncertain! Therefore Strategy B is uncertain - it is exposed to interest rate risk (namely liquidity or price risk) ❑ When an investor’s time horizon is shorter than the term of the bond they are holding, they are exposed to interest rate risk known as liquidity risk ❑ When an investor’s time horizon is longer than the term of the bond they are holding, they are exposed to interest rate risk known as reinvestment risk Example: Liquidity Risk 17 ❑ Strategy B has uncertainty and is more risky. Strategy A is certain and therefore less risky ❑ The Liquidity preference theory refers to the case where most investors in the market have shorter horizons and therefore prefer short-term investments to avoid the liquidity risk of holding long-term bonds ➢ Therefore, investors with shorter term horizons will require a risk premium – called the liquidity risk premium - to hold a longer-term bond (eg the 2 year bond). That is: > () OR = + ❑ This LRP or liquidity risk premium compensates short-term investors for the uncertainty about future interest rates (interest rate risk) Liquidity Preference Theory Further Reading 8AR4: “The Bond Market Term Premium” 18 Interpretation of Yield Curve Theories FINS5513 19 Summary of Theories of Term Structure Expectations Hypothesis Liquidity Preference Theory ❑ = () ❑ = + (LRP > 0) ❑ Forward rates are market expectations of future spot rates ❑ Forward rates are market expectations of future spot rates plus a liquidity premium ❑ The liquidity premium reflects the fact that long term bonds are more risky ❑ Investors with long-term horizons offset those with short-term horizons – therefore no net liquidity premium in the market (the liquidity risk premium is zero) ❑ Investors with short-term horizons dominate the market requiring a liquidity premium to avert liquidity risk ❑ Does not explain the typically upwards sloping yield curve ❑ Explains the typically upward sloping yield curve ❑ The yield curve has an upward bias built into the long-term rates because of the liquidity premium 20 ❑ If there is a liquidity premium the yield curve is biased upward, particularly if the premium increases with maturity Liquidity Premium Impact on the Yield Curve 21 ❑ The yield curve reflects expectations of future interest rates ➢ But the forecasts of future rates are clouded by other factors, such as liquidity premiums ❑ Therefore, an upward sloping curve could indicate: ➢ Rates are expected to rise and/or ➢ Investors require large liquidity premiums to hold long term bonds ❑ The yield curve is a good predictor of the business cycle ➢ Long term rates tend to rise in anticipation of economic expansion ➢ An inverted yield curve may indicate that interest rates are expected to fall and therefore may signal a recession • Read the lecture topic 7 case study carefully to understand exactly why Interpreting the Term Structure Mini Case Study Lecture Topic 7: “Dark Clouds of Yield Inversion” Further Reading 8AR5: “Analysing the Effect of an Inverted Yield Curve on Investors” 8.3 Interest Rate Risk FINS5513 23 Bond Price Sensitivity to Changes in Interest Rates FINS5513 24 ❑ Interest rate sensitivity ① Bond prices and yields are inversely related YTM P ② Bond prices move up in response to an interest rate fall more than they move down in response to the same size interest rate increase (convexity) ③ Long-term bond prices are more interest rate sensitive than short-term bond prices T ΔP ④ As maturity increases, price sensitivity to interest rate changes increases at a decreasing rate ⑤ High coupon bond prices are less interest rate sensitive than low coupon bond prices C ΔP ⑥ Higher YTM bond prices are less interest rate sensitive than lower YTM bond prices YTM ΔP Bond Price Sensitivity to ∆ Interest Rates 25 Bond Price Sensitivity to ∆ Interest Rates ①Downward sloping left to right ②Convex ③ B more sensitive than A ④ Slide 28 ⑤C more sensitive than B ⑥D more sensitive than C 26 ❑ Example 8A2: Rank these bonds in order of interest rate risk: a) A 10 year bond with a 6% coupon and 8% yield to maturity b) A 3 year bond with a 6% coupon and a 8% yield to maturity c) A 10 year bond with a 4% coupon and a 5% yield to maturity d) A 10 year bond with a 4% coupon and 8% yield to maturity ➢ c) 10 year 4% coupon YTM = 5% bond price is: more interest rate sensitive than ➢ d) 10 year 4% coupon YTM = 8% bond price (higher YTM) is: more interest rate sensitive than ➢ a) 10 year 6% coupon YTM = 8% bond price (higher coupon) is: more interest rate sensitive than ➢ b) 3 year 6% coupon YTM = 8% bond price (shorter maturity) Example: Interest Rate Risk 27 ❑ Example 8A3: Consider the following $1000 6% annual coupon bonds with maturities of 1 year, 10 years and 20 years, all trading at a yield to maturity of 6%. a) Price each of the bonds at YTM = 6%. Price each bond assuming YTM changes to 7%. b) What can you say about the relationship between maturity and interest rate risk (i.e. the bond price sensitivity to changes in interest rates)? As the interest rate increases, does the interest rate sensitivity for bonds of different tenor increase/decrease at an increasing or decreasing rate? ➢ Long-term bonds prices are more interest rate sensitive than short-term bond prices T ΔP . That is, longer term bonds have more interest rate risk (principle 3, slide 25) ➢ As maturity increases, price sensitivity to interest rate changes increases at a decreasing rate (principle 4, slide 25) Example: Maturity Impact on Interest Rate Risk YTM 1 year (CR = 6%) 10 year (CR = 6%) 20 year (CR = 6%) 6% $1,000.00 $1,000.00 $1,000.00 7% $990.65 $929.76 $894.06 Change in Price -0.9% -7.0% -10.6% 28 ❑ Example 8A4: Now price $1000 1 year, 10-year and 20-year zero-coupon bonds at a 6% and 7% yield to maturity. Are they more or less sensitive to a change in interest rates than the coupon bonds? Can you explain why? ➢ Zero coupon bond prices are more interest rate sensitive than coupon bonds ➢ Why? More of the return on zeros is “back-ended” so higher interest rates erode present values on zeros proportionately more ➢ If the return is back-ended, does this indicate zero-coupon bonds have longer effective maturity than coupon bonds? ➢ We will discuss the concept of duration next lecture Example: Coupon Impact on Interest Rate Risk YTM 1 year (Zero) 10 year (Zero) 20 year (Zero) 6% $943.40 $558.39 $311.80 7% $934.58 $508.35 $258.42 Change in Price -0.9% -9.0% -17.1 29 ❑ BKM Chapter 16 ❑ 8.4 Measuring Interest Rate Risk: Duration ❑ 8.5 Managing Interest Rate Risk: Immunisation Next Lecture